Photo AI
Mark is charged with an offence and the matter is brought to court by a police prosecutor - HSC - SSCE Legal Studies - Question 10 - 2015 - Paper 1
Question 10
Mark is charged with an offence and the matter is brought to court by a police prosecutor. It is his first offence. Mark is found guilty and sentenced. What type of... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:Mark is charged with an offence and the matter is brought to court by a police prosecutor - HSC - SSCE Legal Studies - Question 10 - 2015 - Paper 1
Step 1
What type of offence and penalty would most likely apply to Mark?
Answer
To determine the most likely type of offence and penalty for Mark, we need to consider the nature of charges and typical outcomes for first-time offenders in similar situations.
Since Mark has been convicted for the first time, it is likely that he was charged with a summary offence. Summary offences are generally less severe and one of the common penalties for such offences includes fines.
Among the options provided:
- Option (A) suggests a summary offence and a fine, which aligns with the context of a first-time offender dealing with a minor charge.
- Option (B) introduces imprisonment for a summary offence, which is uncommon and often reserved for more serious cases.
- Option (C) posits an indictable offence and a suspended sentence, which is also unlikely given his first offence status.
- Option (D) mentions an indictable offence with a good behaviour bond, which again seems too severe for a first offence.
Thus, the most appropriate choice that reflects the typical response in this situation is (A) A summary offence and a fine.