Photo AI
Charlie: Would you ever accept someone’s theory if it couldn’t be proven logically? Robin: No - HSC - SSCE Studies of Religion - Question 18 - 2020 - Paper 1
Question 18
Charlie: Would you ever accept someone’s theory if it couldn’t be proven logically? Robin: No. All statements and theories are meaningless, unless they can be verif... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:Charlie: Would you ever accept someone’s theory if it couldn’t be proven logically? Robin: No - HSC - SSCE Studies of Religion - Question 18 - 2020 - Paper 1
Step 1
How would Charlie and Robin best be described?
Answer
In analyzing Charlie and Robin's perspectives:
-
Charlie presents ideas that align more closely with humanism. He believes in the meaning of propositions, even if they cannot be logically proven, suggesting a focus on human experience and values that transcend empirical evidence.
-
Robin, on the other hand, strictly adheres to logical reasoning and empirical verification, indicating an atheistic perspective that negates claims without evidence.
Thus, the most fitting description based on their dialogue is: A. Charlie is a humanist and Robin is an atheist.