Photo AI
'Trial by jury is inefficient and outdated.' Discuss two possible reforms to the jury system. - VCE - SSCE Legal Studies - Question 9 - 2013 - Paper 1
Question 9
'Trial by jury is inefficient and outdated.' Discuss two possible reforms to the jury system.
Worked Solution & Example Answer:'Trial by jury is inefficient and outdated.' Discuss two possible reforms to the jury system. - VCE - SSCE Legal Studies - Question 9 - 2013 - Paper 1
Step 1
Possible Reform 1: Broader Representation
Answer
One significant reform to the jury system could be to implement broader representation within juries. This could involve changing the criteria for jury selection to ensure that jurors better reflect the diversity of the community. For instance, the introduction of a more systematic approach to selecting jurors could help ensure that underrepresented groups are included. By doing this, the jury would be more representative of societal demographics, which could enhance the legitimacy of the justice process in the eyes of the public.
Step 2
Possible Reform 2: Improved Jury Instructions
Answer
Another reform would focus on the provision of clear and comprehensive instructions to jurors. Currently, jury members often receive limited guidance on their responsibilities, which can lead to confusion and inefficiency in the deliberation process. By creating a more detailed set of instructions, possibly in the form of a juror's handbook, jurors would be better equipped to understand legal concepts and their roles. This could include specific guidance on how to interpret evidence and apply the law, making the trial process more efficient and fair.