Photo AI
'Changing attitudes towards sustainable tourism, recreation and conservation have meant that local scale ecosystems are no longer under threat.' To what extent do you agree with this view? - AQA - A-Level Geography - Question 6 - 2019 - Paper 1
Question 6
'Changing attitudes towards sustainable tourism, recreation and conservation have meant that local scale ecosystems are no longer under threat.' To what extent do ... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:'Changing attitudes towards sustainable tourism, recreation and conservation have meant that local scale ecosystems are no longer under threat.' To what extent do you agree with this view? - AQA - A-Level Geography - Question 6 - 2019 - Paper 1
Step 1
Introduction to the Question
Answer
In this essay, I will evaluate the assertion that changing attitudes towards sustainable tourism, recreation, and conservation have positively impacted local scale ecosystems. While there are valid points for agreeing with this perspective, there are also counterarguments that highlight ongoing threats to these ecosystems.
Step 2
Discussion of Sustainable Tourism and Conservation
Answer
Sustainable tourism aims to reduce the environmental footprint of tourism activities. Increased awareness and education have led to better management practices in many areas. Conservation initiatives, supported by both local communities and governments, have fostered a greater understanding of the importance of preserving local ecosystems. For example, projects that involve community participation often yield better environmental outcomes, as local populations become stewards of their natural resources.
Step 3
Evidence Supporting the View
Answer
Evidence of success can be seen in various initiatives, such as the Solway Dune restoration Project. This project not only restores habitats but also engages communities in conservation efforts, fostering a sense of responsibility. Additionally, social initiatives like nature-based health walks have improved public awareness and involvement in conservation, demonstrating a shift in attitudes that benefits local ecosystems.
Step 4
Counterarguments to the View
Answer
Despite these positive trends, it is essential to acknowledge ongoing threats. Many ecosystems remain vulnerable due to industrial practices, climate change, and urbanization. The expectation that all local ecosystems are now safe may be overly optimistic, as numerous studies indicate significant declines in biodiversity and habitat loss even in areas with conservation projects. Furthermore, sustainable practices are not universally adopted and often depend on socio-economic factors.
Step 5
Conclusion
Answer
In conclusion, while there are compelling arguments that changing attitudes have somewhat mitigated threats to local scale ecosystems, significant challenges remain. A balanced approach that combines sustainable tourism with strong conservation policies is necessary to ensure the long-term protection of these valuable ecosystems. Ultimately, agreeing with the statement implies recognition of progress but also an awareness of the continuing struggles faced by local environments.