Photo AI

With reference to the source and your own knowledge, what tensions exist between creating a codified constitution and retaining the principle of parliamentary sovereignty? - Edexcel - A-Level Politics - Question 1 - 2018 - Paper 2

Question icon

Question 1

With-reference-to-the-source-and-your-own-knowledge,-what-tensions-exist-between-creating-a-codified-constitution-and-retaining-the-principle-of-parliamentary-sovereignty?-Edexcel-A-Level Politics-Question 1-2018-Paper 2.png

With reference to the source and your own knowledge, what tensions exist between creating a codified constitution and retaining the principle of parliamentary sovere... show full transcript

Worked Solution & Example Answer:With reference to the source and your own knowledge, what tensions exist between creating a codified constitution and retaining the principle of parliamentary sovereignty? - Edexcel - A-Level Politics - Question 1 - 2018 - Paper 2

Step 1

Political Instability

96%

114 rated

Answer

Creating a codified constitution could lead to political instability. This is because constitutional changes often lead to debate and division among parliamentarians, potentially resulting in a loss of public confidence in the government.

Step 2

Parliamentary Binding

99%

104 rated

Answer

A codified constitution suggests that no parliament can bind its successor with any legislation. This raises questions about the permanence and authority of parliamentary acts, creating a tension where the principle of parliamentary sovereignty might be viewed as undermined.

Step 3

Constitutional Arrangements

96%

101 rated

Answer

There might be difficulties in creating constitutional arrangements that allow both a codified constitution and the principle of parliamentary sovereignty to coexist. This tension raises concerns about how legislative power would be distributed.

Step 4

Consensus Issues

98%

120 rated

Answer

Achieving a consensus in parliament regarding the contents and scope of a codified constitution is unlikely. As a body characterized by differing opinions, parliament may struggle to agree, leading to challenges in enacting such a constitution.

Step 5

Judiciary's Role

97%

117 rated

Answer

A shift to a codified constitution would necessitate a greater role for the judiciary in interpreting constitutional provisions, which may conflict with parliamentary sovereignty that emphasizes legislative supremacy.

Step 6

Flexibility vs Rigidity

97%

121 rated

Answer

The introduction of a codified constitution may bring rigidity, whereas parliamentary sovereignty allows for adaptiveness. This could lead to tensions between maintaining flexibility in governance and adhering to a fixed constitutional framework.

Join the A-Level students using SimpleStudy...

97% of Students

Report Improved Results

98% of Students

Recommend to friends

100,000+

Students Supported

1 Million+

Questions answered

;