Photo AI
How does Kelly use the character of John Tate to explore ideas about good and bad leaders? Write about: • what John Tate says and does • how Kelly uses John Tate to explore ideas about good and bad leaders. - AQA - GCSE English Literature - Question 7 - 2021 - Paper 1
Question 7
How does Kelly use the character of John Tate to explore ideas about good and bad leaders? Write about: • what John Tate says and does • how Kelly uses John Tate ... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:How does Kelly use the character of John Tate to explore ideas about good and bad leaders? Write about: • what John Tate says and does • how Kelly uses John Tate to explore ideas about good and bad leaders. - AQA - GCSE English Literature - Question 7 - 2021 - Paper 1
Step 1
what John Tate says and does
Answer
John Tate's character is pivotal in illustrating the complexities of leadership. Initially, he attempts to calm his peers, indicating a desire to take control of the situation. His attempts, however, are undermined by his struggles with self-doubt, as he expresses that he finds the environment 'stressful.'
Moreover, Tate's actions throughout the narrative reveal his gradual shift from a position of authority to one of solitude, with his eventual disappearance from the group symbolizing the consequences when a leader fails to take decisive and positive action. This is compounded by his involvement in bullying, where he asserts dominance rather than supportive leadership.
Step 2
how Kelly uses John Tate to explore ideas about good and bad leaders
Answer
Through John Tate, Kelly explores contrasting leadership styles and the impact they have on individuals and groups. Tate's initial interactions highlight the struggle of a leader facing overwhelming pressure and the ineffectiveness of his bullying as a means of control.
Kelly also illustrates how Tate's behavior reflects a deeper commentary on human psychology and leadership. Tate's shift towards self-isolation echoes the idea that true leadership requires emotional intelligence and the ability to unify rather than divide.
By presenting Tate’s eventual 'finding God' as a transformative moment, Kelly suggests that redemption is possible for those who recognize their failures as leaders. Furthermore, through the reactions of the other characters, the audience gains insight into the varying perceptions of leadership, ultimately questioning what qualities make a good leader.