Study Source A in the Sources Booklet - AQA - GCSE History - Question 1 - 2020 - Paper 1

To determine that Source A is critical of Germany during the First World War, we can analyze the content and context of the source itself.

Firstly, the language used in Source A may exhibit negative connotations towards Germany. For example, words or phrases indicating aggression or blame can signify a critical stance. It is essential to look for specific examples in the text or image that showcase this critical viewpoint.

In addition to analyzing the language, we should consider the context of the First World War. Germany's actions during the war, such as unrestricted submarine warfare, led to significant global criticism. Contextually, if Source A references these events, it further supports the interpretation that it is critical of Germany.

Furthermore, understanding the provenance of Source A—who produced it, when, and for what purpose—can provide insight into its intended message. If the source was created in response to negative perceptions of Germany at that time, this also indicates a critical perspective.

Conclusively, a thorough analysis of the text combined with contextual historical knowledge reinforces the understanding that Source A is indeed critical of Germany.