In this extract, there is an attempt to show the relationship between Lucy and Sir Michael - Edexcel - GCSE English Language - Question 4 - 2021 - Paper 1

The passage begins with a dramatic silence, which reflects Lucy's unusual initial response to Sir Michael's proposal of marriage. This response can be interpreted in multiple ways - is she thoughtful, shocked, or perhaps conflicted?

The imagery of the setting sun at the end of the day acts as a poignant symbol of Sir Michael's idealized view of love, contrasted with Lucy's broader perspective on their relationship. Her act of kneeling at his feet exemplifies the stark difference in their respective social statuses, highlighting the power dynamics at play.

The phrase 'might love' not only questions the purity of her feelings but also suggests that Lucy does not regard herself as deserving of such love. This illustrates her internal struggle, shaped by her recollections of her difficult childhood, which she openly shares with Sir Michael, indicating her vulnerability.

Furthermore, Sir Michael's inquiry, 'Do you dislike me?', reflects his profound misunderstanding of Lucy's sentiments, implying that his affections are either unreciprocated or misinterpreted. The black ribbon, symbolizing a burden Lucy carries, adds complexity to her character, showcasing her tumultuous feelings.

The internal monologue revealed through Lucy's reflections points to a suppressed emotional connection, leading to her hesitance in fully embracing Sir Michael's love. This incapacity fosters a significant tension in their relationship, emphasizing the divergence in their emotional landscapes.

Ultimately, the writer deftly creates an understanding of the relationship between Lucy and Sir Michael, portraying it as fraught with misunderstanding and emotional complexity through detailed and symbolic narrative techniques.