Photo AI
Study Sources A and B in the Sources Booklet - Edexcel - GCSE History - Question 2 - 2018 - Paper 1
Question 2
Study Sources A and B in the Sources Booklet. How useful are Sources A and B for an enquiry into the treatment of battle injuries by medical staff on the Western Fr... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:Study Sources A and B in the Sources Booklet - Edexcel - GCSE History - Question 2 - 2018 - Paper 1
Step 1
How useful are Source A for an enquiry into the treatment of battle injuries?
Answer
Source A provides a photograph of a casualty clearing station, which is significant in contextualizing the environment where minor injuries were treated. It suggests that treatment facilities were established close to the front line, allowing for immediate care. However, the photograph's intention may have been to reassure the public rather than provide an accurate representation of everyday medical practice, which somewhat limits its reliability as a source.
Step 2
How useful are Source B for an enquiry into the treatment of battle injuries?
Answer
Source B is a diary extract that highlights the nature of injuries treated and the emotional experiences of the patients and medical staff. It provides valuable first-hand accounts of the types of injuries that were addressed, reinforcing the severity and complexity of medical responses during the conflict. While it offers a personal perspective, the subjective nature of diary entries may affect its objectivity in reflecting the broader practices of medical staff.
Step 3
Consideration of historical context and overall assessment.
Answer
Both sources contribute to an understanding of the medical treatment associated with battle injuries. Source A illustrates the infrastructure established for quick medical responses, while Source B conveys the human experience of that treatment. However, neither source is exhaustive, and caution should be taken in interpreting them without additional context regarding medical advancements and practices on the Western Front.