Photo AI
Figure 2 and Figure 3 show a tennis serve in an outdoor doubles match and its classification on the open-closed skill continuum - Edexcel - GCSE Physical Education - Question 5 - 2019 - Paper 1
Question 5
Figure 2 and Figure 3 show a tennis serve in an outdoor doubles match and its classification on the open-closed skill continuum. Figure 2 Tennis player serving Open... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:Figure 2 and Figure 3 show a tennis serve in an outdoor doubles match and its classification on the open-closed skill continuum - Edexcel - GCSE Physical Education - Question 5 - 2019 - Paper 1
Step 1
Closed skills are not affected by the environment
Answer
A tennis serve is not completely classified as a closed skill because it can be influenced by various external factors. Closed skills are generally characterized by being performed in a stable and predictable environment. In tennis, the player may face distractions during the serve, such as movement from the opponent or noise from the crowd, which can affect their performance.
Step 2
Example of factors
Answer
-
Being distracted by opponent moving/crowd making noise: The presence of an opponent or a noisy environment can disrupt the server's concentration, impacting the execution of the serve.
-
If it's windy affecting the ball toss: Wind conditions can make it difficult to achieve a consistent ball toss, which is essential for a successful serve.
-
If it's sunny needing to change technique: Bright sunlight might require adjustments in technique to ensure the ball is served accurately.
-
If it's wet/raining the surface may be slippery: Weather conditions can lead to an unstable serving environment, thus affecting grip and foot placement.
Step 3
It is more open because conditions are not always identical
Answer
The tennis serve is considered more open because the environmental conditions vary and are not always predictable. For instance, factors such as wind, crowds, and changing weather can impact how a player serves. Unlike closed skills, which are performed in consistent environments, the tennis serve must adapt to these varying conditions, making it a skill requiring flexibility and quick adjustments.