Photo AI
Choose a non-fiction text which provokes a strong reaction in the reader - Scottish Highers English - Question 8 - 2019
Question 8
Choose a non-fiction text which provokes a strong reaction in the reader. By referring to appropriate techniques, discuss how the writer creates this reaction.
Worked Solution & Example Answer:Choose a non-fiction text which provokes a strong reaction in the reader - Scottish Highers English - Question 8 - 2019
Step 1
Choose a non-fiction text which provokes a strong reaction in the reader.
Answer
For this prompt, I have chosen the non-fiction text 'The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks' by Rebecca Skloot. This text not only uncovers the story of Henrietta Lacks and her contributions to medical research but also evokes a strong emotional response from the reader, primarily due to its exploration of ethical issues in science and human dignity.
Step 2
By referring to appropriate techniques, discuss how the writer creates this reaction.
Answer
In 'The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks', Rebecca Skloot employs several techniques to evoke a strong reaction from readers:
Personal Anecdotes
Skloot utilizes personal anecdotes throughout the narrative, particularly in her portrayal of Lacks' family. By sharing their struggles with the legacy of Henrietta's cells, she humanizes the scientific story, allowing readers to connect emotionally with the characters.
Ethical Discourse
The text discusses the ethical implications of medical research without consent. Skloot raises profound questions about morality in the scientific community, which compels readers to reflect on their own beliefs regarding autonomy and dignity in medical ethics.
Vivid Descriptions
The author employs vivid descriptions that create relatable and poignant imagery. This technique immerses the reader in the setting and circumstances of Lacks’ life and legacy, effectively heightening empathy for her situation.
Juxtaposition of Perspectives
Skloot contrasts the experiences of scientists with those of Lacks' family, emphasizing the disparities in societal power and representation. This juxtaposition serves to highlight injustices faced by marginalized individuals in scientific advancements, stirring feelings of anger and sadness in readers.
Through these techniques, Skloot effectively provokes emotional reactions, prompting a deeper understanding of the complex issues surrounding race, ethics, and scientific progress.