Compare the views of Sources A and B about the experience of Italian immigrants in Scotland - Scottish Highers History - Question 10 - 2018

The views in Source A and Source B highlight various aspects of the experience of Italian immigrants in Scotland.

Source A emphasizes the individual success of an Italian family in Campbeltown, showcasing how they established a thriving business in the fish and chips and ice cream trade. This indicates a positive experience characterized by entrepreneurship and community growth, where the ability to create businesses led to the emergence of several Italian cafés. The narrative illustrates the hard work and dedication of the family members, which facilitated their adaptation and integration into Scottish society.

In contrast, Source B provides a broader perspective on the Italian immigrant experience, focusing on the cultural contributions Italians made to the food industry. It raises questions about their unique position in primarily taking over these trades. It points out that many Italian immigrants lacked prior experience in these trades but adapted quickly to meet local needs. This shows the involvement of Italian immigrants not only as business owners but as essential workers providing services in a community where the Scots were in need of labor, particularly during the economically challenging times of the 1920s.

Ultimately, both sources recognize the impact of Italian immigrants on the Scottish economy, but Source A leans more towards personal success stories, while Source B underscores the cultural and economic reliance between Scots and Italians.