Photo AI
How much do Sources A and B reveal about differing interpretations of the reasons for the growth of Protestantism by 1560? Use the sources and relevant knowledge. - Scottish Highers History - Question 5 - 2023
Question 5
How much do Sources A and B reveal about differing interpretations of the reasons for the growth of Protestantism by 1560? Use the sources and relevant knowledge.
Worked Solution & Example Answer:How much do Sources A and B reveal about differing interpretations of the reasons for the growth of Protestantism by 1560? Use the sources and relevant knowledge. - Scottish Highers History - Question 5 - 2023
Step 1
Source A: Understanding David Lindsay's Perspective
Answer
Source A indicates that by the 1550s, there was significant dissatisfaction within Scotland regarding the Catholic Church, as expressed by David Lindsay in his play 'The Three Estates'. Lindsay highlights that Scots were torn between loyalty to the old Church and the new Protestant ideas. This reflects a divided perspective and suggests that the desire for reform stemmed from both loyalty to the old faith and the need for change. Lindsay's indication that people believed the Church needed reform highlights the mixed motivations behind the support for Protestantism.
Step 2
Source B: Voices of Reform and the Wider Public Response
Answer
In Source B, Jenny Wormald discusses how people were influenced by preachers and the excitement surrounding reform. The source illustrates that many people, including nobility, were drawn to Protestant ideas through religious opposition and public sentiment. Wormald emphasizes how varying interpretations were shaped by individual experiences with the Church, further supporting the notion that the growth of Protestantism was both a top-down and bottom-up phenomenon. The passion for reform expressed in this source contrasts with Lindsay's more conflicted view by showing a clearer shift towards embracing Protestant ideals.