Photo AI
How much do Sources A and B reveal about differing interpretations of the reasons for the growth of Protestantism in Scotland before 1560? Use the sources and recalled knowledge. - Scottish Highers History - Question 5 - 2019
Question 5
How much do Sources A and B reveal about differing interpretations of the reasons for the growth of Protestantism in Scotland before 1560? Use the sources and recal... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:How much do Sources A and B reveal about differing interpretations of the reasons for the growth of Protestantism in Scotland before 1560? Use the sources and recalled knowledge. - Scottish Highers History - Question 5 - 2019
Step 1
Source A Interpretation
Answer
Source A highlights the internal struggles of the church before 1560, noting that certain segments of the congregation and clergy recognized a need for reform due to the church's failure to meet its spiritual responsibilities. This acknowledgment of corruption and mismanagement within the church may have fueled the growth of Protestantism, as critics sought to address these failings.
Step 2
Source B Interpretation
Answer
In contrast, Source B focuses on John Knox's efforts to promote Reformed Protestantism after his return to Scotland. It suggests that his activism and the context of political crisis in Scotland during this time were pivotal in spreading Protestant ideas. Knox's recognition of the turbulence facing the church adds a layer of urgency to the Protestant cause.
Step 3
Overall Comparison
Answer
Collectively, these sources illustrate differing interpretations: Source A leans towards internal church factors like corruption, while Source B emphasizes external influences and key figures like Knox in mobilizing Protestant sentiment. Both perspectives are critical in understanding the multifaceted reasons behind Protestantism's growth in Scotland.