Compare the views of Sources A and B about commemoration and remembrance - Scottish Highers History - Question 13 - 2018

Sources A and B both emphasize the significance of creating a national memorial in Scotland, although they approach the subject from different angles.

Agreement on Location: Both sources agree that Edinburgh Castle is the most suitable location for the national memorial. Source A mentions that Edinburgh Castle was determined to be the best site, while Source B reinforces this notion by stating that public opinion was strongly in favor of the Castle Rock as the location.

Importance of National Identity: Source A points out that the creation of the memorial was seen as a way for Scots to commemorate their own sacrifices during the war, reflecting a sense of pride and collective identity. The phrase, "put up with their own hands in their own country," implies a significant emotional investment by the Scottish people.

Conversely, Source B highlights that the Scottish memorial was inherently linked to national identity, reinforcing the idea that it would be built by Scots for Scots. This highlights a commitment to ensuring the memorial represented Scottish values and contributions.

Public Sentiment: There is a clear reflection of public sentiment in both sources, showcasing a strong desire among Scots to honor their war heroes. Source A discusses concerns over the potential impact on the skyline of Edinburgh, demonstrating a dialogue about preserving cultural heritage in the face of new constructions. Meanwhile, Source B illustrates overwhelming public support for building the memorial at Edinburgh Castle, which emphasizes the collective desire to remember the sacrifices made during the war.

In summary, both sources agree on the importance and location of the memorial, but they illuminate differing concerns regarding national pride and public opinion, shedding light on the complex motivations behind commemoration and remembrance in Scotland.