Photo AI
Compare the views of Sources A and B about attitudes towards Union with England - Scottish Highers History - Question 7 - 2018
Question 7
Compare the views of Sources A and B about attitudes towards Union with England. Compare the sources overall and in detail.
Worked Solution & Example Answer:Compare the views of Sources A and B about attitudes towards Union with England - Scottish Highers History - Question 7 - 2018
Step 1
Overall Comparison
Answer
Both Sources A and B discuss the implications of the Union with England, albeit from different perspectives.
Source A presents a positive outlook on the Union, suggesting that it brings security and benefits for Scotland, emphasizing the potential for economic growth and investments in colonies. In contrast, Source B highlights a more cautious stance, indicating fears regarding the loss of freedom and representation within the new framework of governance.
Step 2
Source A Analysis
Answer
Source A argues that the Union enhances Scotland’s security against foreign threats and promotes economic cooperation with England. The source emphasizes that Scottish citizens will benefit from the rights of being British citizens, as well as the possibility of free trade and investment.
Furthermore, it suggests that the Union will allow Scotians to trade more effectively and enjoy a better standard of living.
Step 3
Source B Analysis
Answer
Source B, in contrast, articulates a concern that the Union entails forfeiting vital freedoms. It mentions the worries expressed in the petition regarding the potential restriction of rights and representation.
Moreover, it reflects a skepticism about the assurance that their interests will be safeguarded, hinting at a mistrust of the English governance structure.
Step 4
Conclusion
Answer
In conclusion, while Source A favors the Union and outlines its advantages for Scotland, Source B expresses trepidation about potential negative outcomes. This divergence illustrates the complexity of attitudes toward the Union, with economic optimism conflicted by fears of political marginalization.