14.2.4 Post-modern feminism

Post-Modern Feminism

Intersectionality

The term was originally coined by Crenshaw and argues that the mainstream feminist movement had focused mostly on the plight of white, college-educated, middle/upper-class women who had no stake in the concerns of women of colour.

Modern Feminism

Third Wave Feminism

• Most female goals have been achieved over the second wave.
• Reject simplistic approach to feminism - issues such as race and ethnic situation must be considered.
• Patriarchy continues to adapt & find new ways to oppress women (e.g., genital mutilation).
• Intersectional: gender, race, religious & influence.

Context

Postmodern feminism emerged as a critique of earlier feminist theories, particularly those that sought universal explanations for women's experiences. It aligns with postmodernism's broader rejection of grand narratives and fixed truths, focusing instead on the diversity and complexity of women's identities and experiences.

---

The State

Relativism in State Authority

Postmodern feminists argue that the state's authority is not absolute and should be questioned. They emphasize that state power is constructed through discourses that often reflect the interests of dominant groups rather than universal truths.

Critique of State Intervention

Unlike some feminist perspectives that call for more state intervention to address gender inequalities, postmodern feminism is wary of such interventions. It stresses that state policies can inadvertently reinforce existing power structures, including patriarchy.

Advocacy for Decentralized Governance

Postmodern feminists often support decentralized forms of governance that allow for more localized and context-sensitive approaches to issues like gender equality, rather than one-size-fits-all state policies.

---

Society

Multiplicity of Social Realities

Postmodern feminism asserts that there is no single, overarching social reality. Instead, it emphasizes that society is composed of multiple, overlapping realities that vary based on individual experiences and identities.

Deconstruction of Identity Categories

Society often relies on rigid categories of identity (e.g., male/female, heterosexual/homosexual). Postmodern feminists challenge these categories, arguing that they are socially constructed and limit the diversity of human experiences.

Power Relations in Social Norms

Postmodern feminists highlight how social norms are deeply embedded in power relations. They critique these norms as tools that maintain the dominance of certain groups, particularly in terms of gender, race, and class.

---

The Economy

Economic Discourses and Power

Postmodern feminists examine how economic systems are maintained through discourses that naturalize inequality. They challenge the narratives that justify economic disparities as inevitable or natural.

Focus on Marginalised Economic Voices

Postmodern feminists bring attention to how traditional economic theories often overlook or marginalize the experiences of women, especially those from minority groups. They advocate for an economy that considers the needs and voices of these marginalized groups.

Resistance to Commodification

Postmodern feminism critiques the way capitalism commodifies aspects of identity, such as gender and race. They argue that this commodification reduces complex identities to marketable stereotypes, perpetuating both economic and social inequalities.

---

Key Concepts

Social Construction of Gender

• Deconstruction of Gender Norms: Postmodern feminists seek to deconstruct traditional gender roles and norms, exposing how they are created and maintained by societal power structures. They argue that these norms are used to perpetuate gender inequality.

Critique of Universalism

• Emphasis on Difference: This strand of feminism highlights the importance of acknowledging differences among women, including those based on race, class, sexuality, and culture. It rejects the idea that there is a single, universal experience of womanhood.

Intersectionality

• Challenging Power Structures: By focusing on intersectionality, postmodern feminists aim to challenge not only gender-based oppression but also how different forms of oppression intersect to create unique experiences of marginalisation.

Critique of Power and Knowledge

• Discourses and Gender: Postmodern feminists examine how discourses (ways of speaking and thinking) shape our understanding of gender and perpetuate patriarchal power. They seek to disrupt and challenge these discourses to create space for more diverse and inclusive ways of thinking about gender.

---

Key Thinkers

Judith Butler

• Subversion of Gender Norms: Butler suggests that by subverting traditional gender performances (e.g., through drag), individuals can challenge and destabilize entrenched gender norms.

Bell Hooks

• Critique of Dominant Narratives: hooks critiques how mainstream feminist movements have often excluded the voices and experiences of Black women and other marginalized groups. She calls for a more inclusive feminism that recognizes and values diverse perspectives.

---

Criticisms of Postmodern Feminism

• Relativism: Critics argue that postmodern feminism's rejection of universal truths can lead to relativism, where it becomes difficult to advocate for any specific feminist goals or policies.
• Lack of Political Action: Some suggest that by focusing on deconstructing discourses and identities, postmodern feminism may neglect the need for concrete political action to address material inequalities and injustices.

Contribution to Feminism

• Focus on Language and Power: It has brought attention to the ways in which language and power shape our understanding of gender and has encouraged feminists to think critically about the narratives they use to advocate for change.