Sign of Four: Themes

Key Themes in The Sign of the Four

1. Justice and Vengeance
2. Colonialism and Empire
3. Greed and Corruption
4. The Role of Women

---

Justice and Vengeance

The theme of justice and vengeance is central to The Sign of the Four, with the characters' actions often driven by a desire for retribution or a sense of duty.

Key examples:

5. Jonathan Small's Quest for Vengeance: Jonathan Small's pursuit of the treasure is motivated by a desire for justice and vengeance against those he believes wronged him. Conan Doyle uses Small's character to explore the thin line between justice and vengeance, and how the desire for retribution can consume a person.
6. Sherlock Holmes' Pursuit of Justice: Holmes' relentless pursuit of the truth and his dedication to solving the case reflect his commitment to justice. His character embodies the ideal of using intellect and reason to uncover the truth and ensure that justice is served.

---

Colonialism and Empire

Colonialism and the British Empire are significant themes in The Sign of the Four, influencing the plot and the characters' motivations.

Key examples:

7. The Indian Mutiny and the Treasure: The backstory of the treasure and its origins during the Indian Mutiny highlights the impact of British colonialism on the lives of both the colonisers and the colonised. Conan Doyle uses this to comment on the moral complexities and consequences of empire, particularly the exploitation and greed that often accompanied it.
8. Tonga's Character: The portrayal of Tonga, a native of the Andaman Islands, reflects the racial prejudices and stereotypes of the time. Conan Doyle's depiction of Tonga as a "savage" reflects the colonial mindset, which viewed non-European cultures as inferior and dangerous.

---

Greed and Corruption

Greed and corruption are recurring themes in The Sign of the Four, driving much of the conflict and tragedy in the story.

Key examples:

9. The Sholto Family's Greed: The Sholto brothers' greed for the Agra treasure leads to betrayal and murder, illustrating how the pursuit of wealth can corrupt individuals and destroy relationships. Conan Doyle uses their story to show the destructive power of greed.
10. The Treasure as a Symbol: The Agra treasure itself becomes a symbol of greed, with various characters willing to lie, betray, and kill to possess it. The treasure's cursed nature suggests that wealth obtained through immoral means brings only misery and destruction.

---

The Role of Women

The role of women is a subtle but significant theme in The Sign of the Four, reflecting the gender norms and expectations of the Victorian era.

Key examples:

11. Mary Morstan's Role: Mary Morstan's character, though central to the plot, is often portrayed as passive and dependent on the male characters. Conan Doyle uses her character to reflect the limited roles available to women at the time, where they were often relegated to the sidelines in both social and personal spheres.
12. The Lack of Female Agency: The novel's female characters, including Mary Morstan, are largely defined by their relationships with men and have little agency in the events that unfold. This reflects the broader societal expectations of women in Victorian England, where women were often expected to be passive and dependent on male protection.