9.2.2 Environmental Issues & Religious Teachings

Key Ethical Issues Surrounding the Environment

Pollution:

Pollution, including air, water, and land pollution, harms ecosystems, wildlife, and human health. It also contributes to climate change, which disproportionately affects the poorest and most vulnerable communities, raising questions about justice and responsibility.

Climate Change:

Climate change, driven largely by human activities such as burning fossil fuels, deforestation, and industrial processes, is a significant ethical issue. It poses severe threats to the environment, including rising sea levels, extreme weather events, and loss of biodiversity. Climate change also raises moral questions about the responsibility of current generations to future generations, the duty to protect vulnerable populations, and the need for global cooperation to address this crisis.

Christianity: The Use and Abuse of the Environment

1. Stewardship:

• Biblical Basis: The idea of stewardship is rooted in the Bible, particularly in Genesis 2:15, where God commands Adam to "work it and take care of" the Garden of Eden. This implies that humans should use natural resources wisely and avoid causing harm to the environment.

2. Ethical Issues:

• Overuse of Resources: Christians believe that the overuse of natural resources is a form of abuse that disrespects God's creation. Ethical concerns arise when resources are exploited without regard for the long-term consequences, leading to environmental degradation.
• Pollution: Pollution is seen as a violation of the stewardship duty, as it harms God's creation and the well-being of all living beings. Christians are called to reduce pollution and seek sustainable practices to honor their responsibility to care for the earth.

3. Teachings on Sustainability:

• Sustainable Living: Many Christians advocate for sustainable living, emphasizing the need to balance human needs with the health of the environment. This includes promoting renewable energy, reducing waste, and supporting conservation efforts.
• Social Justice: Christian teachings often link environmental care with social justice, highlighting the impact of environmental degradation on the poor and marginalized. This perspective calls for equitable distribution of resources and protection of vulnerable communities from the effects of pollution and climate change.

Islam: The Use and Abuse of the Environment

1. Khalifah (Stewardship):

• Qur'anic Basis: The Qur'an emphasizes the role of humans as stewards in verses such as Surah Al-Baqarah 2:30, where Allah appoints humans as His representatives on earth. This stewardship involves using resources responsibly and avoiding harm to the environment.

2. Ethical Issues:

• Use of Resources: Islam teaches that natural resources are a gift from Allah and should be used judiciously and fairly. Wastefulness is strongly discouraged, as it goes against the principles of stewardship and respect for God's creation.
• Pollution: Pollution is considered a form of harm ("fasad") to the earth, which is prohibited in Islam. The Qur'an warns against corruption and harm to the earth in Surah Al-Rum 30:41, which calls on Muslims to avoid destructive practices that damage the environment.
• Climate Change: In Islam, the principle of balance ("Mizan") is central to environmental ethics. Climate change is seen as a disruption of this balance, and Muslims are encouraged to combat climate change by adopting sustainable practices, reducing waste, and supporting global efforts to address environmental degradation.

3. Teachings on Environmental Balance:

• Mizan (Balance): Islam emphasizes the concept of "Mizan" (balance), which refers to the natural equilibrium created by Allah. Muslims are encouraged to maintain this balance by living in harmony with nature and avoiding actions that disrupt it, such as excessive consumption or environmental destruction.
• Accountability: Islamic teachings stress that humans will be held accountable for their actions, including how they treat the environment. This belief motivates Muslims to adopt environmentally friendly practices, reduce pollution, and engage in conservation efforts.

Comparative Ethical Issues

1. Stewardship vs. Khalifah:

2. Pollution and Sustainability:

• Both religions recognize pollution as a serious ethical issue, seeing it as a violation of the divine mandate to protect the earth. Sustainable practices are encouraged in both faiths, with a focus on reducing waste, conserving resources, and ensuring the well-being of future generations.

3. Climate Change:

• Both Christianity and Islam recognize the importance of addressing climate change, viewing it as a moral obligation to protect the planet for future generations. Both faiths call for action to reduce carbon emissions, support environmental sustainability, and promote global cooperation to combat climate change.

4. Social Justice and Environmental Ethics:

• Christianity and Islam both link environmental care with social justice, emphasizing the impact of environmental harm on the poor and vulnerable. This connection highlights the ethical responsibility to ensure that environmental policies and practices do not disproportionately affect disadvantaged communities.