Poetry

Hotel Room, 12th Floor - Notes

Summary of the poem:

• Norman MacCaig's "Hotel Room, 12th Floor" reflects on the cityscape of New York from a hotel room in the morning.
• It explores the contrast between the modern, technological achievements represented by skyscrapers and the primitive, violent nature of humanity.
• The poem begins with a light-hearted comparison of the Empire State Building to a dentist's drill but gradually becomes sombre.
• It delves into the idea that even in the modern world, darkness and violence persist, symbolised by the arrival of midnight.
• The sounds of sirens, screaming, and violence in the streets suggest the ongoing battle between progress and primal instincts.
• The poem concludes by emphasising that the frontier of uncivilised darkness is not somewhere else but within humanity, highlighting the persistence of primal impulses.

The inspiration for the poem:

• The poem is inspired by MacCaig's experiences during his visits to New York City in the 1960s.
• It reflects the interest in Scottish literature in America and the influence of the city on MacCaig's writing.
• "Hotel Room, 12th Floor" is part of MacCaig's exploration of the balance between progress and primitive human nature in a rapidly developing urban society.

---

Poetry

The Form of the Poem:

1. Free-Verse: The poem is written in free verse, allowing MacCaig to explore themes without a restrictive structure.

2. Three Stanzas: The poem is divided into three stanzas of varying lengths.

3. Lack of Rhyming Scheme: It does not follow a specific rhyming scheme, providing more flexibility.

Stanza 1:

In the first stanza, the speaker describes the view from their hotel room in New York City in the morning. They observe a helicopter flying close to the Empire State Building, which appears to them like a giant dentist's drill. Initially, there is a light-hearted tone, but it gradually becomes more sombre as the stanza ends with the arrival of midnight, symbolizing darkness and the unknown.

Stanza 2:

In the second stanza, the speaker continues to reflect on the nighttime scene in New York. They are in their hotel room between a radio and a television set, feeling isolated and cut off from the city's life. The sounds of sirens, screams, and violence rise from the streets below, and the stanza paints a bleak picture of urban life, drawing parallels with the Wild West.

Stanza 3:

The final stanza reaffirms the darkness as an ever-present aspect of human nature. The speaker uses the metaphor of "the frontier" to emphasise that the darkness and violence are not confined to the past or distant places but are inherent in humanity. The stanza concludes with a pessimistic statement, asserting that no barriers or "stockades" can keep out the darkness, symbolising the persistence of evil in human society.

---

Poetry

Themes in the Poem:

The Persistence of Primal Instincts:

• Quote: "no stockades can keep the midnight out."
• Development: The poem suggests that despite technological progress, the primal, violent aspects of human nature persist.

The Dark Side of Progress:

• Quote: "a damaged insect" and "giant dentist's drill."
• Development: The poem criticises the superficiality and dark consequences of modern achievements, symbolised by skyscrapers.

Images in the Poem:

Skyscrapers as Symbols of Progress:

• Quote: "a million lit windows."
• Development: The lit windows represent the modern world's progress and its attempt to combat the darkness, but they ultimately fail.

The Wild West as a Metaphor:

• Quote: "the wildest of war whoops continually ululating."
• Development: The sounds of sirens and screams in the city streets are compared to the stereotypical war cries associated with the Wild West, highlighting the persistence of violence.

Style Techniques in the Poem:

Simile:

• Quote: "Like a damaged insect."
• Development: The comparison of the helicopter to a damaged insect conveys the poet's disdain for modern technology.

---

Poetry

Metaphor:

• Quote: "the Empire State Building is a jumbo-sized dentist's drill."
• Development: The metaphor criticises the excessive size and appearance of the building, suggesting that bigger is not necessarily better.

Personification:

• Quote: "midnight has come in/from foreign places."
• Development: The personification of "midnight" arriving from "foreign places" gives it a sense of agency, as if darkness is an active force encroaching on the city. This adds to the ominous atmosphere of the poem, highlighting the relentless nature of the darkness.

Irony:

• Quote: "a million lit windows."
• Development: The use of irony lies in the contrast between the vast number of lit windows and the poem's overall pessimistic message. While the lit windows symbolise progress and civilization, they ultimately fail to dispel the darkness, underscoring the irony of human attempts to conquer primal instincts with technology.

Language Techniques in the Poem:

Synecdoche:

• Quote: "broken bones, harsh screaming, blood glazed."
• Development: The use of synecdoche reduces the victims of violence to their suffering, highlighting the dehumanising effect of brutality.

Alliteration:

• Quote: "glittering canyons and gulches."
• Development: The alliteration of the "g" sound in "glittering," and "gulches" creates a vivid auditory image, emphasising the stark contrast between the modern, illuminated city and the wild, uncivilised nature it represents. This alliteration helps convey the unsettling atmosphere of the poem.

---

Poetry

Negative Word Choice:

• Quote: "never" and "no."
• Development: The use of negative words reinforces the pessimistic tone of the poem, emphasising the futility of trying to keep darkness at bay

Personal Reflection

1. How does the interplay between light and darkness in 'Hotel Room, 12th Floor' provoke thoughts about progress and primal instincts in society?

2. What emotions does the poem's portrayal of urban violence and isolation evoke, and how does it influence your perception of city life and human nature?

3. How does 'Hotel Room, 12th Floor' challenge your views on technology, materialism, and societal disparities in urban settings?