Poetry

Holy Willie's Prayer

Summary of the poem:

• "Holy Willie's Prayer" is a dramatic monologue in which the speaker, Willie, prays while revealing his own prejudiced, hypocritical, and self-interested nature.
• The poem critiques religious hypocrisy, Calvinist beliefs, and the corrupting influence of extreme religious zealotry.

The inspiration for the poem:

• Inspired by a local church dispute involving strict Calvinists (Auld Licht) and more moderate believers (New Licht).
• Gavin Hamilton, Burns' landlord, was tasked with collecting parish fees, often allowing the poor to defer payments, which led to suspicions of theft.
• Willie Fisher (Holy Willie) was assigned to investigate Hamilton, but both were defeated in court.

The form of the poem:

• The poem consists of four sections: Address to God, Confession, Plea for God's Intervention, and Final Request.
• Written in the Standard Habbie stanza, a six-line structure with specific rhyming patterns.
• It is a dramatic monologue, with Willie being the sole speaker, providing a character study.

---

Poetry

Summary of each stanza

Stanza 1: Willie's address to God

Willie opens the poem with a self-praising address to God, highlighting his belief in predestination and his conviction that he is among the chosen "Elect." He portrays God as arbitrary and cruel, willing to send most people to Hell, emphasizing that he is an exception. The stanza illustrates the dark side of extreme Calvinism, where one's devotion can lead to inhumanity.

Stanza 2: Willie's address to God

In this stanza, Willie continues to express gratitude to God for his chosen status and divine grace. He describes himself as a "burning and a shining light," a reference to his own perceived piety. His vision of infants condemned to Hell from birth is unsettling, highlighting the harshness of Calvinist beliefs. Willie's self-praise and self-assuredness are evident.

Stanza 3: Willie's address to God

Willie's self-righteousness continues in this stanza as he lists his symbolic roles in the Kirk (church) and his unwavering faith in God's grace. The stanza exemplifies how he regards himself as equal to any saint, underlining his smugness and pride in his religious position.

Stanza 4: His confession

This stanza takes a turn as Willie confesses his actions, portraying himself as a sexual predator who preys on servant girls. He asks God for forgiveness but justifies his actions by blaming drunkenness. His insincerity is clear as he diminishes the significance of his actions by comparing them to a common occurrence, a baby's crying.

---

Poetry

Stanza 5: His confession

Willie's confession continues with a cynical campaign of sexual exploitation. He argues that God created his flaw as a defense against pride, rationalizing his actions. This stanza underscores his hypocrisy and manipulation of religion to excuse his behavior.

Stanza 6: His confession

Willie seeks to strike a deal with God, promising not to repeat his actions if forgiven. He admits to being afraid of going to Hell. The stanza reveals his self-centered desire for salvation and his willingness to bargain with God, highlighting his true motives.

Stanza 7: A plea for God's intervention

In these stanzas, Willie shifts his focus to calling down God's curse on people who have humiliated him, particularly Gavin Hamilton. He seeks their destruction as revenge for being mocked and defeated in court. The satire intensifies, showing the pettiness and vindictiveness of his desire for revenge.

Stanza 8

Willie asks God to curse those who laughed at him in court and to inflict harm on their livelihood, particularly targeting Gavin Hamilton. His malicious intent and deep-seated desire for revenge are evident in these lines.

Stanza 9

This stanza continues the plea for God's curse, highlighting Willie's obsession with revenge and his desire for those who humiliated him to face divine retribution. The satirical tone is maintained, emphasizing the absurdity of his requests.

---

Poetry

Stanza 10

Willie's plea reaches a climax as he commands God to bring down divine vengeance on his enemies. He uses strong and spiteful language to express his hatred, completely disregarding the principles of Christianity. The stanza showcases the extremity of his vindictiveness and his audacity in commanding God.

Stanza 11

In this stanza, Willie continues to call upon God for vengeance and punishment. His tone remains hateful and spiteful, highlighting the extent of his bitterness and obsession with seeking revenge on those who opposed him.

Stanza 12

Willie's plea for God's intervention continues with further requests for divine retribution. He shows no remorse for his spiteful language or desire for harm to befall his enemies, illustrating the unchristian nature of his prayers.

Stanza 13

This stanza intensifies Willie's curse, particularly targeting Gavin Hamilton by seeking the destruction of his food, specifically potatoes. The juxtaposition of serious religious language with trivial subjects like food underlines the pettiness of his revenge.

Stanza 14

Willie's plea for God's intervention extends to other forms of retribution, and he prays for his enemies' misfortune and suffering. His bitterness and vindictiveness remain pronounced.

---

Poetry

Stanza 15

The speaker continues to call down God's curse on his enemies and seeks their punishment. His language becomes increasingly venomous as he shows no compassion or empathy for those he condemns.

Stanza 16

Willie reaches the culmination of his vindictive prayers, commanding God to try and destroy his enemies. He issues a series of hateful and spiteful commands, oblivious to the irony of a mortal instructing God not to hear the prayers of others.

Stanza 17

In the final stanza, Willie seeks God's blessing and salvation for himself, indicating his fear of eternal damnation. This plea contrasts with the previous stanzas, where he focused on cursing others. It highlights his self-interest and desire for personal salvation.

Themes:

Religious Hypocrisy:

Illustrated by Willie's self-righteousness, condemnation of others, and his own morally questionable actions.

• Quote: "Yet I am here, a chosen sample."
• Development: Willie praises himself while condemning others, revealing his hypocrisy.

Corrupting Effects of Extreme Religious Belief:

Emphasized through Willie's belief in predestination and his judgmental attitude towards those he deems damned.

• Quote: "But Thou remembers, Thou kens, Maybe Thou lets."
• Development: Willie's belief in predestination leads to self-righteousness and moral recklessness.

---

Poetry

Imagery:

Babies Going to Hell:

A vivid image of Calvinist doctrine, where infants are destined for Hell from birth.

• Quote: "Gnash my gums, and weep, and wail, In burnin lakes."
• Development: The poem highlights the disturbing nature of Calvinist beliefs regarding predestination, even for innocent infants.

Curse on Gavin Hamilton's Food:

Willie seeks God's curse on Hamilton's food, particularly potatoes, as a petty act of revenge.

• Quote: "Curse thou his basket and his store, Kail an' potatoes!"
• Development: This image portrays the vindictiveness and pettiness of Willie's desire for revenge.

Style techniques:

Satire:

The poem employs satire to expose the hypocrisy and absurdity of religious zealotry and the speaker's actions.

• Quote: "For their misdeeds!"
• Development: Satirical language emphasizes the exaggeration and absurdity of Willie's call for divine punishment.

Irony:

The poem uses irony to highlight the contradiction between Willie's supposed holiness and his judgmental nature.

• Quote: "This is the ultimate hypocrisy, as Holy Willie is condemning others to hell while boasting about his own righteousness."
• Development: The irony underscores the hypocrisy of the speaker's beliefs and actions.

---

Poetry

Language techniques:

Dialect and Vernacular Language:

Burns uses Scots dialect and vernacular language to capture the authenticity of the poem and the culture of the Scottish people.

• Quote: "fou/When I came near her"
• Development: The use of dialect adds depth and authenticity to the narrative.

Biblical Allusions:

The poem incorporates Biblical language and allusions to emphasize the speaker's religiosity.

• Quote: "But get, O Lord!, O Lord!, Thy servant true"
• Development: The use of Biblical language highlights the speaker's hypocritical piety and self-righteousness

Personal Reflection

1. How does 'Holy Willie's Prayer' challenge your own beliefs about religion, hypocrisy, and self-righteousness?

2. What emotions did you experience while reading the poem, and how does it make you feel about the potential consequences of extreme religious zealotry?

3. In what ways does the poem 'Holy Willie's Prayer' encourage you to reflect on the role of religion in shaping individuals' morality and behaviour?