Photo AI
2. (a) (i) Name one text you studied as part of your comparative course and identify a relationship in it - Leaving Cert English - Question 2 - 2021
Question 2
2. (a) (i) Name one text you studied as part of your comparative course and identify a relationship in it. Explain at least one reason why this relationship... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:2. (a) (i) Name one text you studied as part of your comparative course and identify a relationship in it - Leaving Cert English - Question 2 - 2021
Step 1
Name one text you studied as part of your comparative course and identify a relationship in it.
Answer
One text I studied is Text A. In this text, the relationship between the main character, Alex, and his mentor, Mr. Smith, evolves significantly throughout the narrative. Initially, Alex views Mr. Smith as a guiding figure, but as the story progresses, there is a noticeable tension that arises due to ideological differences. This relationship deteriorates towards the end as Alex’s journey leads him to question Mr. Smith’s values, illustrating a shift from reverence to independence.
Step 2
Explain at least one reason why this relationship either improved or deteriorated over the course of the text.
Answer
This relationship deteriorated largely due to the conflicting beliefs that emerge as Alex develops his identity. Initially, he is influenced by Mr. Smith’s traditional views; however, as he experiences new challenges and perspectives, he begins to see the limitations of his mentor's outlook. This evolution showcases Alex's transformation and the natural conflict that arises when a protégé outgrows a mentor's teachings.
Step 3
Name another text you studied as part of your comparative course and identify a relationship in it.
Answer
Another text I studied is Text B. Here, the relationship between Sara and her estranged father is central to the plot. Initially, there is a deep-rooted animosity and misunderstanding between them, which forms the crux of Sara's internal struggles.
Step 4
Explain at least one reason why this relationship either improved or deteriorated over the course of the text.
Answer
This relationship improves as Sara confronts her past and seeks reconciliation. Through a series of events that unveil hidden truths, both characters begin to understand each other’s perspectives. This reconciliation reflects themes of forgiveness and growth, contrasting sharply with the deterioration seen in Text A.
Step 5
Step 6
Compare how realistic or unrealistic you found the relationships that you identified.
Answer
The deterioration in Text A feels quite realistic, as it mirrors real-life scenarios in which individuals grow apart due to differing beliefs. Conversely, the reconciliation in Text B might appear somewhat idealistic, as such resolutions are not always achievable in real life. However, both relationships highlight significant emotional journeys that resonate deeply with the reader, offering a blend of realism and idealism that enriches the comparative analysis.