Photo AI
Describe how your chosen theme is presented in one of the texts - Leaving Cert English - Question 1 - 2007
Question 1
Describe how your chosen theme is presented in one of the texts. Compare the way in which the same theme is presented in a second text with the way it has been pres... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:Describe how your chosen theme is presented in one of the texts - Leaving Cert English - Question 1 - 2007
Step 1
Describe how your chosen theme is presented in one of the texts.
Answer
In my analysis, I have chosen to discuss the theme of sacrifice as presented in the text 'Text A'. In 'Text A', the theme is conveyed through the character of John, who faces numerous trials that demand substantial personal sacrifice for the greater good. The author uses vivid imagery, such as the depiction of John’s struggles and hardships, to illustrate the emotional weight of his sacrifices. Dialogues among characters further emphasize John’s internal conflict, portraying him as a morally driven individual who grapples with the consequences of his choices. The narrative structure is also significant, as it unfolds in a non-linear way, allowing readers to witness the ripple effects of John's sacrifices on his community and relationships.
Step 2
Compare the way in which the same theme is presented in a second text with the way it has been presented in the text in (a) above.
Answer
In the second text, 'Text B', the theme of sacrifice is presented differently. The character of Alice embodies a more individualistic approach to sacrifice. Starting with the statement 'I thought the theme in my first text was more powerful than the theme in my second text because the context surrounding John’s sacrifices highlighted a collective struggle', whereas Alice makes sacrifices that are more personal and less impactful on society. The theme in 'Text B' focuses on personal gain versus collective well-being, creating a less compelling narrative. Additionally, I enjoyed the theme of personal sacrifice in 'Text A' more than in 'Text B' because the former evokes deeper emotional resonance and presents moral dilemmas that are richer and more thought-provoking.