Photo AI
"Desdemona and Emilia are weak characters who fail to gain our sympathy." To what extent do you agree or disagree with this view of Desdemona and Emilia? Support your answer with reference to the play, Othello - Leaving Cert English - Question E - 2015
Question E
"Desdemona and Emilia are weak characters who fail to gain our sympathy." To what extent do you agree or disagree with this view of Desdemona and Emilia? Support y... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:"Desdemona and Emilia are weak characters who fail to gain our sympathy." To what extent do you agree or disagree with this view of Desdemona and Emilia? Support your answer with reference to the play, Othello - Leaving Cert English - Question E - 2015
Step 1
To what extent do you agree or disagree with this view of Desdemona and Emilia?
Answer
In evaluating the characters of Desdemona and Emilia in Shakespeare's Othello, it is critical to examine their complexities and the societal contexts that shape them.
Desdemona is often viewed as a sympathetic figure who embodies loyalty and idealism. Her strength can be seen in her defense of her love for Othello, despite the tumultuous circumstances—they are bound by mutual affection and respect, indicative of her strong will and dignity. However, one could argue that her passivity in the face of Othello's growing jealousy reveals a weakness in her character, which some may interpret as her failure to gain sympathy from the audience.
Emilia, on the other hand, presents a more pragmatic and realistic perspective. As a character who evolves throughout the play, she initially appears subservient; yet, her ultimate defiance against Iago highlights her strength and humanity. Emilia’s willingness to confront the harsh realities of the male-dominated society invites the audience to empathize with her.
Thus, while both characters exhibit traits considered weak according to societal expectations, they each possess underlying strengths that contribute to their respective journeys. In conclusion, I would argue that Desdemona and Emilia, when fully examined, reveal layers of character that allow for a greater understanding and sympathy from the audience, challenging the notion that they are merely weak characters.
Step 2
"The values evident in Othello have a profound influence on the outcome of the play."
Answer
In discussing the profound influence of values in Othello, two significant themes stand out: loyalty and the impact of societal norms on personal relationships.
The value of loyalty is a central element in the play, manifested in the relationships between characters. Othello's loyalty to Iago, stemming from their friendship, ultimately becomes his tragic flaw, leading to catastrophic decisions. Iago's betrayal of Othello highlights the consequences of misplaced trust, influencing the play's tragic outcome.
Moreover, the play's exploration of societal values surrounding honor, reputation, and race fundamentally shape the actions and fates of the characters. The pressure to conform to Venetian norms—where personal worth is often tied to reputation and societal status—exacerbates the characters' conflicts. For instance, Othello's inevitable downfall is precipitated by Iago's manipulation of these societal expectations, leading to misguided perceptions of honor and integrity.
In conclusion, the values evident in Othello critically inform the play's trajectory, ultimately leading to its tragic resolution.