Photo AI
Describe, in your own words, the scene at the filling station created by the poet in this poem - Leaving Cert English - Question 1 - 2016
Question 1
Describe, in your own words, the scene at the filling station created by the poet in this poem. Some comic books provide the only note of color – of certain col... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:Describe, in your own words, the scene at the filling station created by the poet in this poem - Leaving Cert English - Question 1 - 2016
Step 1
Describe, in your own words, the scene at the filling station created by the poet in this poem.
Answer
The scene at the filling station is depicted as a somewhat chaotic yet familiar environment. The filling station is characterized by a sense of dirtiness, with oil spilling everywhere and creating a feeling of discomfort. The poet describes the father figure wearing an ill-fitting, oil-soaked monkey suit, emphasizing the unsettling atmosphere.
There is a familial aspect to the scene, with several sons assisting their father amid the grime, depicting a working-class family dynamic. The image of the cement porch and a dirty dog adds to the homey, yet unrefined quality of the setting. Overall, the filling station presents itself as a place that, despite its filth and disorder, possesses an endearing quality, symbolized by the line 'Somebody loves us all.'
Step 2
Identify a line or phrase from this poem that you enjoy and explain why you enjoy it.
Answer
One line that stands out in the poem is 'Somebody loves us all.' This phrase resonates with me due to its underlying warmth and sense of belonging. Despite the grimy environment depicted throughout the poem, this line introduces a contrasting sentiment of love and care. It suggests that even in less-than-ideal circumstances, there exists a connection and affection among the individuals present. This line encapsulates a sense of hope and community, making it particularly enjoyable and memorable.
Step 3
In your opinion, is Bishop mainly positive or mainly negative about what she sees at the filling station? Support your answer with reference to the poem.
Answer
In my opinion, Bishop's perspective is mainly negative regarding the filling station. She vividly portrays the place as dirty and uninviting, emphasizing the filth and chaos surrounding the family running the station. Phrases like 'Oh, but it is dirty!' clearly express her discomfort and disapproval of the environment.
However, there are moments of positivity, as illustrated by the familial interactions among the grease-smeared sons and their father. Yet, the overwhelming impression is one of distaste; the various descriptions of oil, dirt, and the oddities of the scene highlight her critical view of such a life. Overall, the poem skews negative, emphasizing the struggle within a challenging environment.