Photo AI
1. (a) Describe the occasion in the novel when Mr Elton makes a proposal of marriage to Emma - Leaving Cert English - Question 1 - 2012
Question 1
1. (a) Describe the occasion in the novel when Mr Elton makes a proposal of marriage to Emma. (b) In your opinion, is Mr Knightley a suitable husband for Emma? Supp... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:1. (a) Describe the occasion in the novel when Mr Elton makes a proposal of marriage to Emma - Leaving Cert English - Question 1 - 2012
Step 1
Describe the occasion in the novel when Mr Elton makes a proposal of marriage to Emma.
Answer
In the novel "Emma," the occasion of Mr. Elton's proposal occurs after he and Emma return from a dinner with the Westons. During the carriage ride, Mr. Elton expresses his affection for Emma with great enthusiasm. Emma, taken by surprise, is shocked by his proposal as she had misunderstood his intentions, believing he was enamored with Harriet Smith instead. This moment reveals Mr. Elton's arrogance, as he expects Emma to return his feelings without regard for her prior sentiments toward Harriet. The proposal is characterized by tension and awkwardness, especially as Emma struggles with her response and the realization that Mr. Elton's feelings have been misinterpreted. Ultimately, what ensues is a frosty encounter, highlighting the misunderstandings and complexities of social relations at play.
Step 2
In your opinion, is Mr Knightley a suitable husband for Emma? Support your answer with reference to the text.
Answer
In my opinion, Mr. Knightley is a suitable husband for Emma for several reasons. Firstly, they have a long-standing friendship, marked by mutual respect and understanding. Their ability to disagree and reconcile is a testament to the strength of their relationship. Knightley's character contrasts with the more frivolous members of their social circle; he is grounded, rational, and has Emma's best interests at heart. Additionally, he offers her a moral compass, guiding her decisions with wisdom and care. For instance, his concern for Harriet's wellbeing demonstrates his capacity for compassion, which complements Emma's sometimes misguided intentions. Their intellectual compatibility and emotional bond suggest that they would be able to form a stable and fulfilling partnership.
Step 3
Explain what you find most interesting about Frank Churchill.
Answer
What I find most interesting about Frank Churchill is the enigmatic nature of his character. He is shrouded in mystery; little is known about him at first, which creates a sense of intrigue. His failure to visit his newly-married father and his secret relationship with Jane Fairfax reveal layers of complexity. Moreover, Frank's apparent indifference towards the feelings of Emma and Jane causes tension in the narrative. His character oscillates between charm and superficiality, making it difficult for other characters, and the reader, to fully trust his intentions. This duality adds depth to the story, as his actions have significant repercussions for the dynamics within the group, ultimately leading to revelations about loyalty, love, and social expectations.