Photo AI
1. (a) Describe an occasion from the text when you think Nora Clitheroe behaves badly towards her husband, Jack - Leaving Cert English - Question 1 - 2018
Question 1
1. (a) Describe an occasion from the text when you think Nora Clitheroe behaves badly towards her husband, Jack. (b) In your opinion, does Nora generally behave ba... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:1. (a) Describe an occasion from the text when you think Nora Clitheroe behaves badly towards her husband, Jack - Leaving Cert English - Question 1 - 2018
Step 1
Describe an occasion from the text when you think Nora Clitheroe behaves badly towards her husband, Jack.
Answer
In Sean O'Casey's play, Nora Clitheroe demonstrates bad behavior towards her husband, Jack, primarily during her emotional outbursts. One notable occasion occurs when she refuses to support Jack's desire to seek a more peaceful existence away from the turmoil of the political conflict. Instead of empathizing with Jack's plight as he struggles with his fears and responsibilities, she belittles him and continues to argue about their situation. This act not only undermines Jack's feelings but also reveals Nora's selfishness, as she prioritizes her own emotional needs over her husband's well-being.
Step 2
In your opinion, does Nora generally behave badly towards Jack? Explain your answer with reference to the text.
Answer
Generally, Nora does exhibit behaviors that can be perceived as bad towards Jack. She often dismisses his concerns and displays a degree of emotional volatility. For instance, her insistent need for attention and validation can lead to moments of neglect towards Jack's emotional state. Additionally, when she exhibits jealousy or resentment, particularly regarding his interactions with other characters, it further alienates Jack and exacerbates tensions in their relationship. While one could argue that Nora is a product of her environment, her actions often indicate a lack of understanding and consideration for Jack.
Step 3
Identify a moment in the play, The Plough and the Stars, which you find particularly dramatic or exciting. Explain what makes this moment so dramatic or exciting.
Answer
A particularly dramatic moment in the play occurs when Jack decides to join the fight despite Nora's protests. This scene captures the intense conflict between personal sacrifice and social duty. As Jack prepares to leave, the tension escalates, illustrating the emotional stakes involved. Nora's desperation to keep Jack from going heightens the drama, showcasing her fear not just for his life, but for the disintegration of their family unit. The raw emotions displayed during this moment serve to underline the broader themes of loyalty and the impact of war on personal lives, making it a pivotal point in the narrative.
Step 4
Write about the importance of either loyalty or betrayal in the play, The Plough and the Stars.
Answer
Loyalty and betrayal serve as central themes in The Plough and the Stars, illustrating the complexities of human relationships amidst the chaos of war. Characters often confront their loyalties—whether to family, friends, or their country—which leads to moments of betrayal and personal conflict. For instance, Nora's loyalty to Jack is tested when he chooses to fight, showcasing how societal pressures can push individuals to act against their better judgment. This theme resonates throughout the play, prompting audiences to reflect on the cost of loyalty and the personal sacrifices that come with it.