Photo AI
Would you agree that Charles Stewart Parnell’s achievements and failures were both significant? Explain your answer. - Leaving Cert History - Question 2 - 2018
Question 2
Would you agree that Charles Stewart Parnell’s achievements and failures were both significant? Explain your answer.
Worked Solution & Example Answer:Would you agree that Charles Stewart Parnell’s achievements and failures were both significant? Explain your answer. - Leaving Cert History - Question 2 - 2018
Step 1
Significance of Parnell's Achievements
Answer
Charles Stewart Parnell was a crucial figure in the Irish nationalist movement during this period. His key achievements included the unification of various nationalist factions, leading to a more coherent political strategy aimed at achieving Home Rule for Ireland. His leadership in the Land League also highlighted the struggles of Irish farmers against landlordism, bringing attention to land reform issues in a way that had never been done before. Parnell's ability to galvanize public support and mobilize protests helped to set the stage for future reform efforts.
Furthermore, Parnell's work laid the groundwork for later political successes, emphasizing issues such as tenant rights and agricultural reform. His charisma and strategic mindset were instrumental in bringing the Irish question to the forefront of British politics.
Step 2
Significance of Parnell's Failures
Answer
Despite his achievements, Parnell also faced significant failures which impacted his legacy. The split within the Irish nationalist movement, particularly following the scandal surrounding his personal life, undermined his influence and ultimately weakened the movement he had worked so hard to build. This division was detrimental because it highlighted the tensions between various factions in Irish politics and led to a disorganization that would take years to rectify.
Moreover, his inability to maintain a consistent alliance with British politicians limited his effectiveness in gaining concessions for Ireland, showcasing that while he was a master organizer, he struggled with political alliances that could have advanced his goals further.