The Searchers

Overview

• "The Searchers" by Tracy K. Smith is from her second collection, Duende (2007).
• The poem is inspired by the 1956 John Ford Western film of the same name.
• It reimagines a scene featuring Ethan Edwards, a Civil War veteran, as he grapples with prejudice and personal honour.
• Themes explored include loss, identity, control, and the tension between human will and life's uncontrollable forces.
• Using vivid imagery, sharp questions, and a reflective tone, the poem invites readers to explore the emotional and philosophical complexities of living, belonging, and letting go.

---

Detailed Summary

Stanza 1:

The poem opens with a stark statement: "He wants to kill her for surviving" (line 1), immediately introducing Ethan Edwards' hatred for his niece Debbie's survival among the Comanche tribe. The rawness of this line underscores his prejudice, rooted in a refusal to accept her assimilation into the Native American culture. Her actions, like clutching her skirt as she runs, suggest her desperation and divided identity.

Stanza 2:

Instead of killing her, Edwards takes physical control, "puts her / On his saddle, rides back / Into town" (lines 5–7). Taking her home is not necessarily heroic; it is portrayed as a forceful imposition of his will. The phrase "She barely remembers" highlights Debbie's disorientation and the emotional toll of her experiences.

Stanza 3:

The townspeople greet Debbie with kindness and curiosity, but their "questions and the wish, / The impossible wish, to forget" (lines 9–10) reveal their misunderstanding of her trauma. The repetition of "wish" emphasises the futility of erasing the past, posing a universal question: "What does living do to any of us?" This line shifts the focus from Debbie's personal story to a broader reflection on human suffering.

Stanza 4:

Smith uses the vivid metaphor of a rider gripping the "ribs of a horse / Past commanding" (lines 13–14) to symbolise humanity's attempt to control life's uncontrollable forces. The image of the horse as a "beast" that could easily throw the rider illustrates how fragile human control truly is, despite our constant efforts to impose order.

Stanza 5:

The poem expands its scope with the haunting image of a "chimney burning in the mind" (line 22), evoking memories of a lost home and a past life. The speaker reflects on the futility of nostalgia, as the "rocker still rocks", but the people it belonged to are gone. This suggests that time erases even the strongest human connections.

Stanza 6:

A rhetorical question, "Why do we insist our lives are ours?" (line 25), challenges the illusion of control over our existence. Smith contrasts human insistence with the indifferent frontier landscape, which "didn't resist" and "Gave anyone the chance / To plant shrubs, dig wells" (lines 26–28). The natural world's openness contrasts sharply with humanity's tendency to cling to ownership and control.

Stanza 7:

The landscape is personified as "Watched, not really concerned / With whether it belonged / To him or to him" (lines 29–31), reflecting its indifference to human struggles. The poem ends on a stark and fatalistic note: "The land went on living, / Dying. What else could it choose?" (lines 32–33). This closing observation highlights the inevitability of life and death, leaving the reader to reflect on the futility of human efforts to impose meaning or control.

---

Themes

Control and Powerlessness

The poem repeatedly questions humanity's obsession with control and ownership, especially in the face of forces larger than ourselves. The metaphor of the rider gripping the "ribs of a horse / Past commanding" (lines 13–14) reflects our futile attempts to dominate life, which is as unpredictable and untameable as a wild beast. The rhetorical question "Why do we insist our lives are ours?" (line 25) highlights this struggle, suggesting that human control is often an illusion. The indifferent landscape, which "Watched, not really concerned / With whether it belonged / To him or to him" (lines 29–31), reinforces the idea that nature and life continue unaffected by our claims of dominance.

Identity and Belonging

The poem explores the complexities of identity through the character of Debbie, who has survived her time with the Comanche tribe but is no longer the person her uncle recognises. The line "clutching / Her skirt as if life pools there" (lines 3–4) symbolises her struggle to hold on to her sense of self amidst the cultural and personal upheaval. The townspeople's "impossible wish, to forget" (line 10) reflects a desire to erase the aspects of her identity that don't fit their expectations, raising questions about how much of our identity is shaped by others and what it means to truly belong.

The Inevitability of Life and Death

The poem closes with the stark realisation that life and death proceed regardless of human effort or intervention: "The land went on living, / Dying. What else could it choose?" (lines 32–33). This fatalistic tone permeates the poem, suggesting that human struggles—whether for identity, control, or meaning—ultimately pale in comparison to the relentless cycles of nature. The rocking chair and burning chimney, symbols of a vanished home, emphasise how time erases even our most cherished connections, leaving only memories behind.

---

Structure and Form

1. Free Verse

The poem is written in free verse, with no fixed rhyme scheme or metre. This open structure mirrors the raw, reflective nature of the speaker's observations, allowing the poem to flow naturally like thought or conversation. It also mirrors the unpredictability of the themes it explores, such as identity, powerlessness, and mortality.

2. Stanza Structure

The poem is divided into seven uneven stanzas, with a mix of shorter and longer lines. This uneven structure reflects the fragmented nature of memory and the disjointedness of the speaker's reflections on control, identity, and belonging. For example, shorter stanzas such as stanza 7 ("The land went on living, / Dying. What else could it choose?") offer striking finality and an impactful conclusion.

3. Enjambment

Smith uses enjambment throughout the poem to create a sense of momentum and flow. For instance: "And why do we grip it, hang on / As if it's the ribs of a horse" (lines 13–14).

The enjambment between these lines emphasises the tension of the speaker's questioning, drawing the reader into the rhythm of their thoughts. This technique mirrors the urgency of the speaker's philosophical inquiries.

4. Use of Direct Address and Questions

The poem frequently addresses the reader directly through rhetorical questions: "What does living do to any of us?" (line 11) and "Why do we insist our lives are ours?" (line 25). This conversational style invites the reader to engage personally with the poem's reflections, creating a tone of shared introspection.

5. Open-Ended Conclusion

The poem ends with an unresolved question: "What else could it choose?" (line 33). This use of an open-ended conclusion mirrors the uncertainty of the poem's central themes—identity, control, and mortality—leaving the reader to grapple with these issues without a definitive answer.

Poetic Techniques

1. Imagery

• "Clutching / Her skirt as if life pools there" (lines 3–4): This striking image captures Debbie's desperation and fractured identity, as she clings to something familiar while navigating a world that feels alien to her.
• "A chimney burning in the mind" (line 22): The metaphor of the burning chimney evokes a vivid sense of nostalgia, symbolising the lingering warmth of memory even after the home and its people are gone. Effect: The imagery draws the reader into the speaker's emotional and philosophical reflections, grounding abstract ideas in concrete, sensory experiences.

2. Metaphor

• "As if it's the ribs of a horse / Past commanding" (lines 13–14): This metaphor compares life to a wild horse, emphasising humanity's struggle to control what is inherently untamable.
• "The land went on living, / Dying" (lines 32–33): The land is personified as a living entity, symbolising the indifferent and unstoppable forces of nature and time. Effect: These metaphors add depth to the poem's exploration of control, reminding the reader of the fragility of human efforts in the face of larger, uncontrollable forces.

3. Repetition

• "The impossible wish, to forget" (line 10): The repetition of "wish" highlights the futility of trying to erase trauma or rewrite history, underlining the persistence of memory.
• "To him or to him" (line 30): The repetition of "him" emphasises the indifference of the land to human ownership, reinforcing the theme of nature's impartiality to human struggles. Effect: Repetition amplifies key ideas, making the speaker's questions and reflections resonate with greater emotional weight.

4. Rhetorical Questions

• "What does living do to any of us?" (line 11): This question invites the reader to consider the emotional toll of life and the universal struggles it entails.
• "Why do we insist our lives are ours?" (line 25): This question challenges the reader's assumptions about control and ownership, encouraging introspection. Effect: The use of rhetorical questions creates a conversational tone, drawing the reader into the poem's themes and making them a participant in its inquiry.

5. Personification

• "Watched, not really concerned / With whether it belonged" (lines 29–30): The land is personified as an indifferent observer, standing apart from the human drama unfolding on it. Effect: By giving the land a detached presence, Smith underscores the theme of humanity's powerlessness in the face of nature's indifference, making the reader reflect on their place in the larger world.