Photo AI
Disorder brings chaos, resulting in the shattering of peace and stability - NSC English HL - Question 14 - 2019 - Paper 2
Question 14
Disorder brings chaos, resulting in the shattering of peace and stability. Critically assess the validity of this statement in relation to the play. Your response s... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:Disorder brings chaos, resulting in the shattering of peace and stability - NSC English HL - Question 14 - 2019 - Paper 2
Step 1
Introduction
Answer
In Arthur Miller's play, The Crucible, the assertion that disorder brings chaos, leading to the shattering of peace, is fundamentally explored through the lens of the Salem witch trials. The structured society of Salem is challenged by hysteria and absolute disbelief, underpinning the theme that disorder instigates chaos and destabilizes social harmony.
Step 2
Assessing Social Disharmony
Answer
Initially, Salem operates under strict social rules governed by Puritan beliefs. However, this rigidity makes it susceptible to disorder when the girls, led by Abigail Williams, challenge these societal norms. Their actions trigger chaos as they accuse others of witchcraft, notably Elizabeth Proctor, showcasing how individual ambition can disrupt community stability.
Step 3
Hysteria and the Collapse of Order
Answer
The ensuing hysteria further amplifies the disorder in Salem. As Parris and Hale attempt to restore order, their efforts ironically exacerbate the problem. Parris's self-interested motives and Hale's misguided attempts to root out witches lead to increased accusations and panic, illustrating how efforts to impose order can spiral into chaos.
Step 4
The Role of the Judiciary
Answer
Moreover, the failure of the judicial system underlines the theme of shattering stability. Corrupt judges prioritize their reputation over justice, allowing the innocent to be condemned. This highlights that when those in power lose integrity, the social fabric disintegrates, leading to turmoil within the community.
Step 5
Conclusion
Answer
In conclusion, Miller effectively critiques the inherent fragility of societal order through the disarray seen in The Crucible. The play serves as an example of how disorder, born from personal vendettas and societal pressures, ultimately dismantles peace and stability, validating the initial statement profoundly.