Photo AI
What is suggested by the phrase, 'down there' (line 3) in the context of the poem? Account for the use of brackets throughout the poem - NSC English HL - Question 4 - 2019 - Paper 2
Question 4
What is suggested by the phrase, 'down there' (line 3) in the context of the poem? Account for the use of brackets throughout the poem. Refer to line 24: 'His free... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:What is suggested by the phrase, 'down there' (line 3) in the context of the poem? Account for the use of brackets throughout the poem - NSC English HL - Question 4 - 2019 - Paper 2
Step 1
What is suggested by the phrase, 'down there' (line 3) in the context of the poem?
Answer
The phrase 'down there' suggests a sense of physical and emotional distance experienced by the prisoners. It conveys isolation and the idea that the prisoners are confined not only in a physical space but also in their interactions with others. This reinforces their lack of contact with the outside world and emphasizes their entrapment.
Step 2
Account for the use of brackets throughout the poem.
Answer
The brackets in the poem serve to enclose translations and interpretations of sign language used by the prisoner. This allows readers to understand the complexity of communication happening behind the scenes. Additionally, the use of brackets invites the reader into the conversation, making them an active participant in interpreting the dialogue.
Step 3
Refer to line 24: 'His free hand, the talkative one'.
Answer
In this line, the word 'free' is used ironically as it depicts the prisoner who is technically constrained yet has a means of communication through gestures. This highlights the contradiction of being able to express oneself while physically restricted. The mention of 'taktive' also implies that despite the limitations imposed, there remain avenues for communication.
Step 4
Discuss the irony in this line.
Answer
The irony lies in the fact that while the prisoner is imprisoned and unable to speak freely, his hand communicates effectively. The phrase 'talkative one' juxtaposes the silence imposed on him with the expressive capabilities of his hand, suggesting that communication transcends verbal interactions even in the most restrictive situations.
Step 5
Step 6
Is the title appropriate in the context of the poem? Justify your response.
Answer
Yes, the title is appropriate as it embodies the spirit of ubuntu, which emphasizes interconnectedness and mutual support among humans. In the poem, the experiences of the prisoners reflect the need for empathy and solidarity. The title encapsulates these themes, reinforcing the importance of humanity and compassion in overcoming the challenges faced by individuals in isolation.