Photo AI
TEXT F: CARTOON Officer, I: lathered around the car, and getting back, my car is stolen - NSC English HL - Question 4 - 2016 - Paper 1
Question 4
TEXT F: CARTOON Officer, I: lathered around the car, and getting back, my car is stolen. Frame 1 Get this straight... Frame 2 You actually understand me? You’re... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:TEXT F: CARTOON Officer, I: lathered around the car, and getting back, my car is stolen - NSC English HL - Question 4 - 2016 - Paper 1
Step 1
What does the officer's facial expression in FRAME 3 reveal about his attitude?
Answer
The officer's facial expression in FRAME 3 reveals a sense of realization and attentiveness. He appears surprised and eager to help, as indicated by his statement, "Gigs! I’ll get the car, sir; wait for me!" This suggests a shift from initial disbelief to a willingness to assist, reflecting a positive turn in his attitude towards the woman's situation.
Step 2
Comment on the impact of the last frame conveying the cartoonist's message.
Answer
The last frame effectively conveys the cartoonist's message by highlighting the gap between the officer's actions and the woman's serious complaint. The contrast between the woman's distress and the officer's sudden enthusiasm underscores a critique of public officials who prioritize their personal interests over the needs of citizens. This creates a humorous yet thought-provoking commentary on the ineffectiveness of the banking system.
Step 3
In FRAME 2, the cartoonist uses a technique that is different from those used in FRAMES 1 and 3. Discuss the effectiveness of this technique.
Answer
In FRAME 2, the cartoonist employs the absence of dialogue to create a moment of tension and reflection. This technique draws attention to Garfield's reactions and emphasizes his self-scrutiny, contrasting with the prior frames that feature more direct interactions. This absence allows readers to focus more intently on Garfield's expressions, enhancing the emotional impact of the scene.
Step 4
Discuss the humour in the cartoon by making reference to both the visual and the verbal elements.
Answer
The humour in the cartoon is largely derived from irony. In the Garfield strip, the cat's absurd look at himself breeds a sense of self-awareness that makes the reader laugh. Jon's literal interpretation of the cat's words creates an unexpected twist, as he misunderstands the humorous nature of Garfield's questioning. The interplay between visuals and dialogue adds depth to the humour, making it both relatable and entertaining.