Photo AI
'An Abandoned Bundle' – Mbiyueni Oswald Mtshali 2.1 'Caught' suggests that the people are unable to escape the hardship of life in the township - NSC English HL - Question 2 - 2018 - Paper 2
Question 2
'An Abandoned Bundle' – Mbiyueni Oswald Mtshali 2.1 'Caught' suggests that the people are unable to escape the hardship of life in the township. Just as they are su... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:'An Abandoned Bundle' – Mbiyueni Oswald Mtshali 2.1 'Caught' suggests that the people are unable to escape the hardship of life in the township - NSC English HL - Question 2 - 2018 - Paper 2
Step 1
2.1 'Caught' suggests that the people are unable to escape the hardship of life in the township.
Answer
This line emphasizes the entrapment of individuals within oppressive conditions. The metaphor of being 'caught' conveys the inescapability of their harsh realities, underscoring the societal and environmental struggles faced by the residents.
Step 2
2.2 'Its' is impersonal and usually used when referring to non-human things.
Answer
The use of 'its' signifies a lack of personal connection, reflecting the dehumanisation of the infant. It highlights the absence of individuality, as the infant is stripped of identity, name, and gender, reinforcing the idea that the life of the child is valued less than a human life.
Step 3
2.3 Both were born in humble circumstances but, while Jesus was valued and revered, this infant is not.
Answer
This comparison illustrates the disparity in societal value between the two figures. While Jesus's birth carried significant meaning, the infant's life goes unnoticed and unvalued, erasing its existence and potential to impact the world, mirroring the neglect faced by many in impoverished conditions.
Step 4
2.4 The poem is about the dehumanising effect that apartheid and poverty have on the behaviour of people.
Answer
The narrative critiques the societal implications of apartheid and poverty. By portraying the mother as 'innocent', the speaker elicits sympathy while acknowledging that systemic issues hinder maternal instincts. This perspective suggests that the environment shapes the actions and character of individuals, thereby absolving them of personal blame.