Photo AI
Refer to lines 1–7: 'There are just .. - NSC English HL - Question 5 - 2022 - Paper 2
Question 5
Refer to lines 1–7: 'There are just ... off the vertical.' What impression of the building is created in these lines? (2) Refer to lines 9–10: 'The whole structure ... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:Refer to lines 1–7: 'There are just .. - NSC English HL - Question 5 - 2022 - Paper 2
Step 1
Refer to lines 1–7: 'There are just ... off the vertical.'
Answer
The lines describe a structure that is unstable and precariously balanced. The imagery suggests that the building is at risk of collapse, portraying a sense of urgency and danger. The phrase 'not enough straight lines' emphasizes the chaotic nature of the architecture, implying that the dwelling is constructed haphazardly from varied materials, resulting in a frail and rickety impression.
Step 2
Refer to lines 9–10: 'The whole structure ... towards the miraculous.'
Answer
The term 'miraculous' expresses a sense of wonder at how the building continues to stand despite its precarious construction. It highlights the amazing resilience of the house and its occupants, acknowledging the precarious circumstances while also celebrating their tenacity and faith that the structure will continue to provide them shelter.
Step 3
Refer to line 8: 'Nails clutch at open seams.'
Answer
The word 'clutch' suggests a desperate attempt by the nails to hold the structure together, indicating the fragility of the building. The image of 'open seams' serves to emphasize vulnerability and instability, as if the nails are exerting all their effort to prevent the structure from falling apart. This metaphor is effective in illustrating the overarching themes of precariousness and survival in the poem.
Step 4
Despite the uncertainty of life in these circumstances, the poem offers hope for the future.
Answer
I agree with this statement. The inhabitants of the shelter have demonstrated resilience, gathering 'the light' into themselves, symbolizing hope and potential. The poem illustrates that despite the rickety nature of their dwelling, the occupants cling to faith—suggesting that even in fragile conditions, they have optimism for a better future.