Photo AI
The animals on Animal Farm are victims of circumstance rather than of their own flaws - NSC English HL - Question 6 - 2016 - Paper 2
Question 6
The animals on Animal Farm are victims of circumstance rather than of their own flaws. Critically discuss the extent to which you agree with the above statement. Y... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:The animals on Animal Farm are victims of circumstance rather than of their own flaws - NSC English HL - Question 6 - 2016 - Paper 2
Step 1
Circumstances on Manor Farm
Answer
The initial circumstances on Manor Farm, under the oppressive rule of Mr. Jones, drive the animals to revolt. Their hardships—hunger, neglect, and exploitation—act as catalysts for the rebellion. The animals aim for a better life, believing that their efforts will lead to a just society where they can prosper. However, despite their intentions, the harshness of their environment and their lack of experience ultimately set them up for failure.
Step 2
Flaws of the Animals
Answer
While the animals are indeed shaped by their circumstances, they also exhibit inherent weaknesses that contribute to their downfall. For instance, Snowball's idealistic views, though noble, are marred by naivety, making him an easy target for Napoleon's machinations. This indicates a flaw in their ability to navigate the new power dynamics effectively. Their reluctance to question authority leads to their repeated exploitation, showcasing how their flaws perpetuate their struggles.
Step 3
The Role of Leadership
Answer
The leadership of the animals also plays a critical role in their fate. Initially, Old Major's vision inspires them toward unity and rebellion. However, as power shifts to Napoleon, the animals fail to recognize the gradual degeneration of their principles. Their blind trust in leadership ultimately results in their continued oppression.
Step 4
Conclusion
Answer
In summary, the animals of Animal Farm are undoubtedly victims of their circumstances; however, their flaws, such as naivety, blind trust, and inability to critically assess their leaders, profoundly impact their situation. Therefore, while their environment significantly influences their plight, personal shortcomings also play a crucial role in their tragedy.