Negotiated Settlement and Government

Introduction to the Negotiated Settlement

A. Sociopolitical Climate During the Late 1980s and Early 1990s

• Apartheid Regime: A system of oppression enforcing racial segregation resulted in significant social inequities. For instance, the employment rate for black South Africans was considerably lower than that for whites. These disparities fuelled societal unrest, increasing demands for change.
• Resistance Movements: Protests and widespread unrest within the country challenged apartheid. Individuals and groups called for systemic change, amplifying demands for reform. Reflective accounts from key figures in these movements illustrate the perseverance to end apartheid.
  • Example: Anti-apartheid activists like Desmond Tutu advocated globally for reform.

B. Impact of Economic and Social Crises on the Negotiation Framework

• Economic Decline: GDP growth decreased from 5% in the early 1980s to less than 1% by the late 1980s. This downturn, coupled with rising unemployment, highlighted economic instability and necessitated negotiation.
• International Sanctions: Nations like the UK and USA imposed sanctions, significantly affecting South Africa's economy and prompting policy reconsiderations.
• Internal Pressure: Social crises were crucial. Movements like the "End Conscription Campaign" exerted pressure for policy reform.

C. Key Political Reforms by Apartheid Leaders

• P.W. Botha's Reforms: Introduced the Tricameral Parliament, which failed due to the exclusion of the majority black population.
• F.W. de Klerk's Policy Shift: Instituted significant reforms and delivered pivotal speeches suggesting a move towards negotiation. International reactions were positive, further pressuring the regime.

D. Transition from P.W. Botha to F.W. de Klerk

• The transition was driven by Botha's ill health and ineffective leadership, contrasted by De Klerk's strategic reforms.
• International Reactions: De Klerk's actions garnered international support, easing sanctions and facilitating negotiations. This transition fundamentally shifted political dynamics towards ending apartheid.

E. Release of Nelson Mandela and Unbanning of Anti-Apartheid Organisations

• Nelson Mandela's Release: This was a pivotal moment, symbolising hope and paving the way for open dialogue. Mandela's leadership was crucial in guiding peaceful negotiations.
• Unbanning of Organisations: This redefined the political landscape, allowing open discussions about South Africa's future.

Summarised Outcomes

• The socio-economic environment created undeniable pressure for transformation. Economic decline, driven by both internal resistance and international sanctions, necessitated the reevaluation of apartheid policies.
• Key political reforms and leadership changes underscored the negotiations leading to a new democratic era.
• The release of Mandela and the unbanning of organisations were critical milestones facilitating the transition from apartheid to democratic governance.

Introduction to the 'Whites Only' Referendum

In early 1992, South Africa faced significant socioeconomic pressures and international isolation, necessitating a shift towards a democratic process, marking an essential transition in the country's trajectory.

• Socioeconomic Tensions: The unemployment rate exceeded 40%, with pronounced inequality in resource distribution, fuelling discontent.
• International Isolation: Extensive economic sanctions limited trade, particularly affecting exports, thereby pushing for democratic reforms.

The referendum became crucial in garnering white support, aiming at a negotiation process towards a multiracial democracy.

De Klerk's Political Challenges

• Internal Challenges:
  • National Party Opposition: High-ranking members such as Andries Treurnicht opposed changes, organising rallies to halt shifts from apartheid.
• External Challenges:
  • Economic Sanctions: With GDP growth falling below 1%, sanctions severely restricted economic progression and international trade.

Conduct and Results of the Referendum

• Execution: The vote was exclusively held among the white population to gauge support for reforming apartheid policies.

• Results: An impressive 68.7% voted in favour of reform, marking a significant shift in the country's political landscape.

Legitimisation and Effects on Negotiations

• ANC Reaction:
  • Buoyed by the results, figures like Nelson Mandela spearheaded initiatives for more inclusive negotiations, fostering platforms for public discourse.
• Public Sentiment:
  • Nationally, the referendum outcome indicated readiness for a shift towards inclusive governance, with widespread support for ensuing negotiations.

Reactions from Major Political Entities

• ANC's Response:
  • Enhanced public engagement and heightened discourse led by the ANC—initiation of talks and education at various levels.
• Right-Wing Reaction:
  • The Conservative Party resisted change, organising public demonstrations to maintain the status quo and displaying staunch opposition.

Impact on De Klerk's Strategies

• Short-term Effects:
  • Secured vital political legitimacy to proceed with negotiations, underpinning a mandate for transformation.

• Long-term Strategies:
  • Established avenues for drafting new constitutions and legislative changes, balancing reform with rising political acceptance and challenges.

Diagrams Explained

• The flowchart delineates the chronological steps leading up to the referendum, detailing key events and participants.
• The bar chart visualises the significant majority support for negotiations, crucial for understanding shifts in public sentiment.
• The reaction diagram highlights responses from various entities, showcasing the nuanced external and internal dynamics following the referendum.

Overview of Key Violent Incidents in the 1990s

• Background Factors: Socio-economic issues such as poverty and unemployment exacerbated violence. Historical political rivalries also contributed to unrest.
• Timeline of Events:
  • Focus on KwaZulu-Natal as a region of significant unrest.
  • Differentiate between urban violence in Johannesburg and rural clashes.
  • Key Dates and Outcomes:
    infoNote

    July, 1990: Major urban riots protesting economic conditions.
    March, 1992: Escalating rural clashes led to heightened tensions.
    May, 1993: Efforts at peace accords aimed to unite factions.

Role of Political Parties

• Inkatha Freedom Party (IFP):

  • Detailed analysis of IFP's strategies from conflict to collaboration, including examples of strategic engagements with apartheid officials and the ANC.
  infoNote

  IFP's varying strategies reflected their adaptability to changing political landscapes.

• African National Congress (ANC):

  • Strategic response to violence, enhanced by community involvement. The formation of self-defence units for protection significantly influenced negotiations.
  • Use examples of specific policies or decisions highlighting their combined strategies.

The Boipatong Massacre

• Boipatong Massacre:
  chatImportant

  Date: 17 June 1992
  Impact: The massacre highlighted societal vulnerabilities and disrupted negotiation processes.

  • Discuss the political impacts and immediate negotiation repercussions.
• Statistical Insight:
  infoNote

  Casualties: 45 fatalities; notable community displacement.

Community Reactions and Self-Defence

• Emergence of Self-Defence Units: These units emerged in response to rising violence, with a focused examination of notable leaders.
• Effectiveness & Impact:
  • Outline the advantages and challenges faced by self-defence units using potential anecdotes.
  • Most impactful strategies: An in-depth analysis of strengths and weaknesses.

International Perspectives

• Global Reactions:

  • Examine major nations' responses, such as the USA and UK, focusing on condemnation and diplomatic efforts.

• Consequences:

  • Detail the influence on South Africa's internal dynamics, linking specific actions such as sanctions to political evolutions.

Overview of CODESA I:

• Objective: Create a roadmap for transition to democracy in South Africa.
• Participants: Key figures include Nelson Mandela (ANC) and F.W. de Klerk (National Party).
• Structure:
  • Constitutional Principles Committee:
    • Developed governance frameworks, ensuring a balance of power.
    • Addressed constitutional rights and measures to prevent future abuses.
  • Governance Committee:
    • Focused on establishing government structures at local and national levels.
    • Proposed local administration systems for fair service delivery.
  • Socio-Economic Committee:
    • Engaged in addressing poverty and inequality.
    • Advocated for land redistribution and wealth equity initiatives.

Role of Leaders

• Nelson Mandela:

  • Stressed the importance of inclusivity and equal representation. Supported a majority rule system.
  • Example: Mandela championed land redistribution to address socio-economic disparities, emphasising equity.

• F.W. de Klerk:

  • Concentrated on preserving constitutional protections for minorities.
  • Promoted policies for economic stability.
  • Example: Secured strategies to stabilise financial frameworks, reassuring business interests.

Fundamental Ideological Disagreements

• Majority Rule vs. Power-sharing:

  • Mandela supported majority rule; De Klerk advocated safeguarding minority representation.
  • Example: Consider a town council with 10 members. Under majority rule, decisions would be made by simple majority vote (6 out of 10). Under power-sharing, certain decisions might require a supermajority (8 out of 10) or specific approval from minority representatives.

• Constitutional Guarantees:

  • Essential for safeguarding all citizens' rights, ensuring inclusive governance.

• Economic Redistribution:

  • Divergent views on addressing apartheid-induced inequalities.
  • Example: Land reform proposals ranged from gradual, market-based approaches (favoured by the National Party) to more comprehensive redistribution programmes (supported by the ANC).

Impact of Violent Incidents

• Fostered an environment of mistrust and tension.

The Boipatong Massacre

• Description:

  • Characterised by an attack causing communal violence in the Boipatong township.

• Impact:

  • Eroded trust in the National Party, prompting ANC withdrawal from discussions.

Subsequent Mass Actions

• Community Mobilisation:

  • Strengthened grassroots and international advocacy by the ANC.

• International Response:

  • Protests and calls from global leaders urging accountability.

Recap of Key Points

• CODESA I aimed to facilitate South Africa's transition into democracy through committee-led frameworks and leadership under Mandela and de Klerk.
• Notable ideological divides existed concerning governance models and economic rebalancing.
• Events like the Boipatong Massacre affected the continuity and trust crucial for negotiations.

Diagrams

• This diagram aids in understanding the functions of different committees under CODESA I toward specific goals.
• Offers a visual representation of agreement and ideological clashes among parties.

Background Negotiations Leading to the Record of Understanding

Context: Events Leading to the Record of Understanding

• CODESA I resulted in a negotiation deadlock due to fundamental disagreements.
  • ANC's preference for majority rule conflicted with the National Party's emphasis on protecting minority rights.

Influential Figures

• Cyril Ramaphosa:
  • Played a significant role for the ANC.
  • Propelled momentum in conversations.
• Roelf Meyer:
  • Key figure for the National Party.
  • Bridged communication gaps effectively.

Negotiation Tactics

• Private meetings and personal diplomacy were instrumental in maintaining trust and establishing informal channels.

Essential Agreements and Compromises

Power-Sharing Model

• Establishment of an interim government to manage the transition.
• Involvement of multiple parties ensured a more balanced transition.

Sunset Clause

• The Sunset Clause was a temporary arrangement ensuring minority rights protection during the transition period.

Specific Concessions

• ANC: Consented to a joint-government framework.
• National Party: Accepted a gradual shift towards complete democracy.

Joe Slovo's Contribution

Advocacy for Sunset Clause

• Joe Slovo's advocacy was pivotal in garnering support for compromise measures.

Impact on Negotiations

• Joe Slovo's involvement bolstered trust among civil services, facilitating ongoing dialogues.

Reactivation of Negotiations and Addressing State Violence

Overcoming Mistrust

• Trust was reestablished through open dialogue initiatives and confidence-building measures.

State Violence and Guarantees

• Engaged independent observers to lessen incidents of state-sponsored violence.

Preparation for the Multi-party Negotiation Forum

Organisational Efforts

• Comprehensive preparations for multi-party discussions included logistical planning.

Setting the Stage for Elections

• Implemented international monitoring and revised procedures to ensure unbiased elections.

Diagrams

• 
•